March 2022
Honoring Yesterday – Protecting Tomorrow
Vol. 53, No. 3
March Calendar of Events
2—(Wed.) RESDC Roundup—East County, 3:30 p.m.
Hooley’s Irish Pub, Grossmont Center, La Mesa
8—(Tues.) Virtual RESDC—Elder Abuse in the Time of COVID, 10:00 a.m., Via Zoom Web Conferencing, See Page 1
10—(Thurs.) RESDC Board of Directors Meeting, 9:30 a.m., Via Zoom Web Conferencing
15—(Tues.) Virtual RESDC—Nationwide, County of San Diego Deferred Compensation Program,
10:00 a.m., See Page 1
17—(Thurs.) SDCERA Board of Retirement Meeting,
9:00 a.m.
31—(Thurs.) Cesar Chavez Day
RESDC and SDCERA Holiday.
View the NETWORK
as a printable PDF
Are you on social media?
Stay connected with us!
QUOTE OF THE MONTH
The best way to guarantee a loss is to quit.
▪ Morgan Freeman
UPCOMING RESDC EVENTS AND MEETINGS
We are pleased to announce a few different events & meetings we are planning for March. While we will host our first in-person event in early March, due to ongoing concerns surrounding the pandemic and prioritizing the health and safety of our members, we will continue our offerings of virtual presentations for the immediate future.
The Return of the Popular RESDC Roundup!
We hope to see you (in person!) on Wednesday, March 2, 2022 at 3:30 p.m. at Hooleys in La Mesa at Grossmont Center. The Roundup provides an opportunity to catch up over libations and appetizers with RESDC leadership and fellow members. No reservation required (no host bar). Meet with old friends and make some new ones!
Virtual RESDC Presentation – Elder Abuse in the Time of COVID
Tuesday, March 8, 2022 at 10:00 a.m.
We are pleased to have former Deputy District Attorney (and RESDC member!) Paul Greenwood as our presenter. His presentation, Elder Abuse In The Time Of COVID-19, is sure to provide up-to-date information and resources on how to avoid scams and fraud.
RSVP: To learn more about this presentation, including registration, visit: www.resdc.net/events or you can call our office at 619-688-9229
Virtual RESDC Presentation – Nationwide: County of San Diego Deferred Compensation Program
Tuesday, March 15, 2022 at 10:00 a.m.
Our presenter, Cathie Purdon, a Personal Retirement Consultant with Nationwide will provide information related to the County of San Diego Deferred Compensation Program and as a retiree how to ensure you are on track in managing your plan.
Here’s a message from our presenter: “Live your ideal retirement. Find out strategies, tools, and resources to help you stay on track. What’s your investment strategy in retirement and how is your investment style impacting your investment? How do you plan to offset inflation, higher medical costs, and possible lower Social Security? What is your withdrawal strategy? Is it tax efficient? When do you have to withdraw from your Deferred Compensation to avoid a 50% tax penalty? How is it calculated and how can I withdraw? Do you have Medicare or just preparing for it? What do you need to look out for?”
RSVP: To register for this event visit: www.resdc.net/events or call our office at (619) 688-9229. □
RSVP: To learn more about this presentation, including registration, visit: www.resdc.net/events or you can call our office at 619-688-9229
CESAR CHAVEZ DAY THURSDAY, MARCH 31, 2022
Cesar Chavez Day is a state holiday in California and several other states. The day is commemorated to promote service to the community in honor of Cesar Chavez’s life and work. The holiday celebrates the March 31 birthday and the legacy of the civil rights and labor movement activist Cesar Chavez each year. RESDC and SDCERA will be closed on Tuesday, March 31 in honor of Cesar Chavez Day. □
PRESIDENT’S MESSAGE
By Chris Heiserman
We are saddened by the recent passing of a longtime friend and colleague who embodied the best qualities of unselfish volunteer service in his retirement years, and they were many. Elsewhere in this newsletter you will see a special tribute to this wonderful man – George Shoemaker. He has been a leader and mentor on the RESDC Board of Directors for more than 20 years. We will miss him greatly and remember him fondly for his special contributions to the growth of our organization.
As we approach the deadline for another NETWORK, the state of our COVID-19 pandemic is still unsettled. Unbelievably, predictions are that the United States will reach one million deaths from the virus by April, despite the cautiously optimistic observations from health officials that the worst incidences of new cases are behind us. It’s shocking to me that our country has the highest reported death toll in the world. This has been far from our finest hour. Hopefully we have learned some valuable lessons during this more than two year long pandemic disaster that will leave us better prepared for possible future global health emergencies.
City Pension Reform Failure Costly
It took 12 years and court battles all the way to the California Supreme Court, but the cost to the City of San Diego of undoing the damage to workers affected by the City’s pension reform ballot measure in 2012 is coming into focus. Proposition B was approved by city voters and eliminated traditional pensions for all new hires except police officers. Instead of pensions new employees were given a 401(k)-style retirement account.
Four years ago, the State Supreme Court agreed with a lower court ruling that the proposition was illegally placed on the ballot; the City needed to “make whole” employees denied participation in the regular retirement plan. It has taken months of negotiations with labor unions to reach settlement agreements with two of the largest unions. According to the San Diego Union Tribune, the City will be on the hook for at least $80 million, probably more.
The issue is complicated to say the least. A City report indicates it may have to create retroactive pensions for 3,950 workers hired after the reform was put in place. These first settlements will allow employees to keep their 401(k) accounts instead of getting a pension if they want to. Negotiations are still ongoing with more than 400 firefighters and nearly 100 deputy city attorneys affected by Proposition B. Also still outstanding is the yet to be estimated expense of the City’s liability to another 1,586 former employees impacted by the reform but who left their city jobs.
It is useful to remember that Proposition B was promoted as a major cost-saving initiative when most California cities and counties were experiencing budget challenges in the aftermath of the Great Recession. Proponents claimed that it would be a model reform that others would follow to rein in the escalating expense of public-sector defined benefit retirement programs. It turns out that one other city, San Jose, tried a similar approach. It also ended in failure after the city’s police force began losing personnel to other jurisdictions with better benefits.
Opponents of Proposition B forewarned city officials that erasing pensions for new employees would lead to problems in attracting good candidates for the municipal work force, as well as retaining workers in a competitive public service job market. In addition, hindsight shows us that the most significant savings resulting from the pension reform was a five-year city salary freeze, which only exacerbated recruitment and retention problems.
More than a decade after the people voted in this major controversial change in the City’s retirement benefits, City Councilmembers who played no role in its origin became responsible for reversing it and absorbing its huge price tag. There’s a lesson in there somewhere.
Roundup Pilot
We have scheduled an experiment for March 2nd at Hooley’s in Grossmont Center in La Mesa. We are testing the comfort level of retirees for a return to “in-person” events. Join RESDC leaders and members on the patio after 3:30 p.m. Test results to follow. Stay tuned. □
IN MEMORIAM AND TRIBUTE – GEORGE SHOEMAKER
We regret to inform you that sadly, one of our most veteran Board Members and friend, George Shoemaker passed away recently. Even though it was expected as he was under hospice care, there is always a sense of personal loss when an individual of such enormous stature and formidable accomplishments leaves us.
An active member of RESDC for over 30 years, George retired from the County in 1982 after 27 years of service in the Recorders Office, Auditors Office, and as Assistant to the Director of Electronic Data Processing. He joined the RESDC Board of Directors in January 1998 and served on the RESDC Benefits, Technology, Bylaws and Policy Committees. He also served as RESDC President.
George served as Alternate Retiree Member on the SDCERA Board of Retirement. He also served as President of the California Retired County Employees Association; on the State Intergovernmental Board of Electronic Data Processing; as a representative of all County governments on the Federal Domestic Council in Washington D.C.; and as a member of the RAND think tank that researched the effects of privacy legislation on society. He was also Treasurer of San Diego Safe Harbor, Inc., a transactional housing program for the homeless, and has been an active member of the Pacific Beach Presbyterian Church for over 65 years.
George joined the Navy in 1948, attended the Navy School of Music in Washington D.C. where he earned his degree in Music, and was a member of President Truman’s Inaugural Band. In addition to his BA in Music, George has a BA from San Diego State University in Public Administration, and Associate degrees in Political Science, Accounting, Data Processing, and Information Systems.
He was married for 67 years to his wife Dolores. They had three children of their own, adopted two boys, and have five grandchildren and two great-grandchildren. They loved to travel in their motorhome and made 62 trips across the country as well as many cruises and trips to many foreign countries.
George will be truly missed by the many family members, friends, and colleagues whose lives were touched by his incredible spirit, faith, and love for life. □
RESDC SCHOLARSHIP DEADLINE REMINDER
By Carlos Gonzalez, Scholarship Committee Chair
We want to remind our members that the deadline for students to submit scholarship applications is Friday, March 4, 2022; applications postmarked after this date will not be considered. Final results will be communicated directly to individual participants at the beginning of June. Be sure to remind your graduating high school scholarship applicants to have their applications into the RESDC office by March 4!
The San Diego Foundation has changed the deadline to apply for the Theo and Evelyn Yakel Scholarship. The deadline is Thursday, March 10 at 2:00 p.m.
For more information about the RESDC Scholarship programs please visit: www.resdc.net/scholarship-program. □
MAXIMUM COLA APPROVED FOR RETIREES
SDCERA retired members will get the maximum cost-of-living adjustment (COLA) in their April 29 pension payments:
- Tier I, II and A members: 3% increase
- Tier B, C and D members: 2% increase
For more information, please visit sdcera.org or call SDCERA at (619) 515-6800.
INTRODUCING SDCERA’S MEMBER PORTAL
Retirees can register now for SDCERA’s online member portal. You can access your 1099-R forms anytime, anywhere. Get started at: memberportal.sdcera.org.
This is the first phase of many new features SDCERA has planned for the portal, so stay tuned!
Visit www.sdcera.org for more information, or call the SDCERA Member Service Center at: (619) 515-6800 or email msc@sdcera.org. □
RECENT EVENTS
2022-23 Retirement Fund Contribution Rates Approved by County. The Board of Supervisors has approved the employee and employer contribution rates for the next fiscal year to the $16.2 billion San Diego County Employees’ Retirement Fund. Supervisors okayed the rates recommended in November by the San Diego County Employees’ Retirement Association (SDCERA) Board.
The rates are expressed as a percentage of payroll and the employer rates cover both the normal cost to fully fund retirement benefits for the current county workforce, as well as the amortization of any unfunded actuarial accrued liability (UAAL) for the retirement fund. According to SDCERA’s 2021 Annual Comprehensive Financial Report (CAFR), the unfunded liability of the fund to be amortized over 20 years is $3.668 billion.
The average member rate as a percentage of payroll decreased slightly this year from 11.84% to 11.58%. The employer rates are set to pay for regular (General) workers and employees eligible for Safety retirement benefits. The normal cost rate for General employees is 12.29% of payroll; the normal cost rate for the Safety category is 20.69%. The added rate for the unfunded liability will be 27.57% for General workers and 40.67% for Safety.
The Board agenda letter reported the cumulative rates as 39.86% for the General category and 61.36% for Safety. It said the aggregate rate overall is 44.81% of payroll.
New Report: A Better Bang for the Buck – Post-Retirement Experience Drives Pension Cost Advantage. A new report from the National Institute on Retirement Security finds that defined benefit (DB) plans provide substantial advantages over 401(k) style plans.
From their website located at, www.nirsonline.org, “This analysis finds that (DB) pension plans offer substantial cost advantages over 401(k)-style defined contribution (DC) accounts. A typical pension has a 49% cost advantage as compared to a typical DC account, with the cost advantages stemming from longevity risk pooling, higher investment returns, and optimally balanced investment portfolios.
This report follows two previous analyses conducted in 2008 and 2014 comparing DB plans and DC accounts, and it includes two new elements not included in the previous studies:
1) the impact of the current low interest rate environment; and 2) how saving mid-career rather than early career reduces total retirement savings.”
To access the report, visit: www.nirsonline.org/reports/betterbang3/
New Research: The Great American Retirement Fraud. Recent research by Michael Doran, a professor at the University of Virginia School of Law who also worked for the Office of Tax Policy at the U.S. Treasury Department under two different administrations makes the following case for why our current retirement system doesn’t work. Doran argues in ‘The Great Retirement Fraud’ that legislative reforms alleged to help rank and file American workers save for retirement mostly enhance opportunities for individuals with high incomes. From the research:
“Over the past 25 years, Congress has enacted several major reforms for employer-sponsored retirement plans and individual retirement accounts (“IRAs”), always with large bipartisan, bicameral majorities.
In each case, legislators have claimed that the reforms would improve retirement security for millions of Americans, especially rank-and-file workers. But the supposed interest in helping lower-income and middle-income earners has been a stalking horse for the real objective of expanding the tax subsidies available to higher-income earners.
The legislation has repeatedly raised the statutory limits on contributions and benefits for retirement plans and IRAs, delayed the start of required distributions, and weakened statutory nondiscrimination rules — all to the benefit of affluent workers and the financial-services companies that collect asset-based fees from retirement savings.
The result has been spectacular growth in the retirement accounts of higher-income earners but modest or even negative growth in the accounts of middle-income and lower-income earners.
Despite the benign but misleading rhetoric about enhancing retirement security for everyone, the real beneficiaries of the retirement-reform legislation have been higher-income earners, who would save for retirement even without tax subsidies, and the financial services industry, whose lobbyists have driven the retirement-reform legislative agenda.”
To learn more, visit: www.papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3997927 □
BOARD OF RETIREMENT APPROVES MAXIMUM ALLOWED COLA EFFECTIVE APRIL 1, 2022
The San Diego County Board of Retirement approved an annual cost of living increase, or COLA, for County retirees during their meeting on February 3rd. Most retirees will receive a 3% COLA.
The COLA increases are based on state law, county retirement rules, and changes in the Bureau of Labor Statistics Consumer Price Index for San Diego. County pensions can be increased a maximum of 3% for longer term workers in Tiers I, II and A. Employees in Tiers B, C and D will receive the maximum 2%. The increases will be effective on April 1, 2022.
To affect this COLA adjustment in accordance with state retirement law, the independent actuarial consultant to the Board of Retirement determined that the San Diego Consumer Price Index (CPI) increased by 5.21% in 2021. This amount is rounded to the nearest one-half percent, 5.0%.
County retirement COLAs are also affected by value accumulated in retirees’ COLA Banks. In years when the Consumer Price Index increases more than the 2% or 3% maximums allowed, excess beyond the 2% or 3% is assigned to retirees’ COLA banks. These funds are used to increase the COLA up to the maximum allowed in years when the CPI changes less than the 2% or 3% maximums.
Because the actual CPI exceeds the recommended COLA, Tier I, Tier II and Tier A members will have 2.21% added to their COLA bank and Tier B, Tier C and Tier D members will have 3.21% added to their COLA bank. □
Return to Top
USEFUL CONTACTS FOR COUNTY RETIREES
SDCERA Administration
- Retirement checks
- Withholding forms
- IRS tax forms
- Beneficiary change
- Address change
- Retirement Board meetings
Phone: (619) 515-6800 or (888) 473-2372
Website: www.sdcera.org
Email: msc@sdcera.org
Address: 2275 Rio Bonito Way #100,
San Diego, CA 92108
SDCERA Health Plan Services
Phone: (866) 751-0256
Board of Retirement Members Elected by SDCERA Retired Members
Skip Murphy smurphy@sdcera.org
Alternate—Susan Mallett smallett@sdcera.org
RESDC Administration
- Membership
- Address/email change
- THE NETWORK Editor
- Board of Directors
- Events
- Scholarship programs
- Discounts
Phone: (619) 688-9229 or (866) 688-9229
Website: www.resdc.net
Email: resdc@resdc.net
Address: 8825 Aero Dr., #205, San Diego, 92123
RESDC Endorsed Insurance and Other Supplemental Benefits
- Pacific Group Agencies, Inc.
Phone: (800) 511-9065 - My Senior Health Plan
Phone: (800) 401-2796
San Diego County District Attorney’s Office
- Elder Abuse
Phone: (800) 510-2020 or call 9-1-1
San Diego County Aging & Independence Services
Phone: (800) 339-4661 □
PURCHASE SEE’S CANDIES GIFT CARDS ONLINE
You can now purchase See’s Candies gift cards in our new Online Store using your RESDC discount!
RESDC members are offered $25 gift cards for $22, a savings of $3. Gift cards are redeemable at any See’s Candies location or online.
To purchase gift cards online, go to: resdc.wildapricot.org/online-store. We can only accept credit cards to purchase gift cards online. You may not purchase more than ten gift cards in one transaction.
Note: You need a RESDC member self-service login in order to access the online store. If you need one, please email resdc@resdc.net.
RESDC members are entitled to a 10% group discount on selected items at the two See’s Discount Stores: 3751 Rosecrans Street, San Diego, 92110; and 1830 Marron Road, Carlsbad, 92008. You must ask the See’s sales team which items are selected. You need to show them your RESDC membership card for the discount. Be sure to mention that you are a member of Retired Employees of San Diego County. Occasionally a RESDC member is denied the discount by a clerk at these See’s stores. When this happens, be sure to clarify that you are not an active County employee, but you’re a member of RESDC. The county no longer participates in the See’s group discount program. If you’re still refused a discount, ask to speak to a store manager.
The gift cards are redeemable at any of the See’s retail stores and for online purchases.
If you would like to purchase gift cards through the mail from RESDC, please address an envelope to RESDC, 8825 Aero Drive, Suite 205, San Diego, CA 92123. Enclose a check made out to RESDC for the number of gift cards you would like at $22 for each gift card. Be sure to include postage stamps so we can mail the gift cards to you. Enclose one postage stamp if purchasing less than five gift cards. If purchasing over five gift cards enclose 78 cents of postage. If purchasing over nine gift cards enclose 98 cents of postage. See the postage chart at: www.resdc.net/sees-candies-discount. We will supply the return envelope to put the gift cards into. □
IN MEMORIAM
Gail Arciniega*, Sheriff
Kathleen Armogida, HHSA
George Arndt, Sheriff
Gloria Austin
Ann Banks, Probation
Mildred Bennett, HHSA
Susan Boccaccio
Gracia Dones, HHSA
Janet Dunne, Superior Court
Paul Eckert
Derithe Edwards, District Attorney
Oscar Eusebio, Superior Court
Gary Evans, Registrar of Voters
Gloria Fort
Virginia Gengor
Zenaida Guevarra, Child Support
Ella Herbert
Gerald Hermanson, Facilities Management
Joyce Hexum, County Counsel
Mary Hlawatsch, Probation
Karen Holgate, Public Safety Group
Beverly Horne-Price, Sheriff
Robert Hutchinson, HHSA
Khen Huynh, HHSA
Ihsan Jabbar*, Facilities Management
Junette Johnson, HHSA
Paula Juarez*, Child Support
Lynne Juleson, HHSA
Kathleen Kilday, District Attorney
Nanci Lewis, HHSA
Jorge Lopez*, Fleet Maintenance
Courtland Lowerison
James Magee, Public Works
James McCain, Marshal
Barry Nally, HHSA
Teresa Navarro, Social Services
William Niles, Library
Carolyn Price, Public Defender
Jayne Richards, Probation
James Rogers, Registrar of Voters
Frank Salis, Public Defender
Jose Sevillano, Environmental Health
George Shoemaker, Electronic Data Process
George Sieckman, HHSA
Cynthia Stacy
Catherine Tabacco, Probation
Robert Torbett, Sheriff
Edher Torres*, HHSA
Gilbert Valero, HHSA
John Vigliotti
Mary Walters, Assessor/Recorder/Co Clerk
Martha Wright, Probation
Rosemary Wright
Kent Ziegler, HHSA
*Active Employee
MEMBER PRIVACY
Any retiree or surviving spouse who does not want his/her death notice published in the “In Memoriam” column may notify the RESDC office and your privacy will be maintained.
The Surviving Spouse of a RESDC member is eligible for RESDC membership. For enrollment assistance, please call (619) 688-9229. □
WELCOME NEW MEMBERS
Scott Amos, Sheriff
Barbara Bleichwehl, Superior Court
Samuel Dennis, Children’s
Barbara Flowers
Douglas Frederick, Public Works
Jasmine Gilham*, Health & Human Services
Patti Groulx*
Marilyn Hamilton*, Registrar of Voters
Zulim Obispo*, Child Support
Brenna Ring*
Ian St. John, Probation
Robin Sunkees*, Superior Court
Jannet Wise*, Assessor/Recorder/County Clk
*Associate Members
The surviving spouse of a member is eligible for RESDC membership. For enrollment assistance, please call: (866) 688-9229. □
THE NETWORK is the official monthly newsletter of the Retired Employees of San Diego County, Inc. (RESDC), a private non-profit organization.
The information printed in THE NETWORK is believed to be from reliable sources. However, no responsibility is assumed by THE NETWORK for inaccuracies contained herein.
Business and Inquiries: Business matters and address changes may be recorded on our voicemail at any time, call (866) 688-9229. Please spell your name so the correct member record can be located.
Retired Employees of San Diego County, Inc.
8825 Aero Drive, Suite 205 | San Diego, CA 92123
Office Hours: 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. Monday through Friday
TELEPHONE: (866) 688-9229 Toll Free
FAX: (619) 688-0766
E-MAIL: resdc@resdc.net